The Trouble with Church Music

6 Aug

On the Porch

Onisha Ellis

I'm a winner

Just mention church music in a group and you will see a variety of responses ranging from a shrug to a terrified shiver. Our enemy is having the time of his life ripping churches apart using this beautiful gift from God. If this were a game show, on the one side you have those who love hymns pitted against those who insist on a praise band with contemporary music. In the end, Satan is the only winner.

I have been mulling this for some time and decided to add my thoughts to the conversation.

Everyone in a congregation is a not singer. I once loved to sing, but my vocal cords no longer make a pleasant sound. A long singing session bores me. There I said it. Feel free to label me shallow.

Singing the same chorus over and over does not make me feel more spiritual. Do you remember the Beatles hit song, Hey Jude? It has three minutes of interesting material and the rest is just repetition.

Older persons in the church may be wearing hearing aides to better understand the pastor’s message and the feedback from praise bands going full blast creates misery for them. (I don’t wear one….yet. But my time is coming.)

Younger members live in a fast-paced world and find the slower tempo of hymns b-o-r-i-n-g.

So what can be done to use music in the church the way it should be, to unify the body of Christ in praise of their Savior?

Consider shortening the song portion or breaking it up throughout the service. Experiment until you find the amount of time that fits your congregation.

Become more creative in how we sing. I love Chris Tomlin’s Amazing Grace/My Chains Are Gone. By mixing the beauty of a hymn with a more contemporary sound, he created a moving and inspiring piece of music. I love it when the song director flows the music from one song to another telling the story of what Christ did for you and I  

Sometimes the praise band at our church would begin a song, but then the instruments were silenced and the incredible sound of voices praising God was so beautiful, I would stop attempting to sing and listen to the pure sounds of the congregation’s voices. I think if those with hearing devices knew they could expect something like this each week, it would give them a time to look forward to, rather than dreading the whole singing portion.

One of our larger local churches tried to solve the dilemma by having two services based on music choice. The obstacle to this was who has to get up early? The young people like to sleep in and the older folks take awhile to get moving in the mornings. My husband and I had to declare Saturday a day of rest and refrain from any heavy physical labor so that we could get our achy bodies to cooperate on Sunday morning!

This past weekend, I heard of a creative solution to the music issue. A largish church in Georgia holds two services simultaneously in separate buildings. One service begins with hymns and the other contemporary. The pastor preaches one sermon in “the flesh” (couldn’t resist that) and he is viewed on a screen in the other building. He rotates each week so that a group has him up close and personal twice per month.

It seems like months of thinking on this would have generated more ideas .My grandfather belonged to the Primitive Baptist and they don’t use any instruments at all. Maybe they are on to something. I’m sure you have some thoughts. How about sharing what your church has successfully done or ideas you have?


7 Responses to “The Trouble with Church Music”

  1. rrprewett August 6, 2015 at 12:45 pm #

    In my own experience, I’ve discovered that he problem is not so much with church music, but with me. I keep forgetting that “church” is not a scheduled event designed to make me feel as if I’ve had a worship experience and heard a good sermon — as I define it.

    My eyes were opened, finally, to my problem when I spent a short time trying to minister in an environment of extreme spiritual darkness. I felt as if nothing could have kept me from a gathering of fellow Believers. The peripherals didn’t matter — music styles, theological differences, language barriers — the Body of Christ was meeting, and He was there in our midst. He was the audience of our simple worship, and I had never felt so needy of lifting His name on high. Nor had I felt so needy of the prayers of His people to sustain me for the hours and days ahead.

    You see, the problem is me. It’s what I’m not doing during the week…not living as a disciple, an ambassador, a warrior for His Kingdom, His hands and feet. When I start functioning as a member of His Body, then I long to gather together with my co-laborers so we can rejoice together, weep together, encourage and equip each other, bear each other’s burdens, celebrate together, mourn together, and run into our precious Lord’s presence together. You can do that in any “worship style”.

    But it gets even better. It goes beyond a church meeting to an unfathomable mystery— I get to hang out with the Bride of Christ because I’m part of it! Unfortunately, I have a bad history of trash-talking His bride, but I’m repenting of that. The more I love Him, the more I appreciate His bride. She’s deep and complex, embracing many cultures. He loves that about her. I’m learning to love that too…because I’m learning to see all the ways in which His bride is becoming more and more like Him. Is she changing that much, or is it just me, just mr perspective that’s changing? Am I finally beginning to learn how to love what my Savior loves?

    I think the problem has always been me. I’m so sorry.


    • Old Things R New August 6, 2015 at 2:35 pm #

      Too much of me is the root of many problems in our life. When I find myself getting irritatable I have to back off and check my “me meter”

      I appreciate you stopping by and sharing your experience.

      Liked by 1 person

      • rrprewett August 6, 2015 at 2:36 pm #

        So often true for me too. Sadly.


  2. Louise Gibson August 6, 2015 at 10:47 am #

    Alta. your message today really hit home with me. I stopped going to my church altogether. Our pastor was transfered to another church. There was no longer the traditional hymns, a sermon, etc. We were expected to stand most of the time, sing praise chorouses, etc.with a brief message, if any. I now listen to David Jeremiah on television, who delivers a beautiful sermon with a traditional message.


    • Old Things R New August 6, 2015 at 11:11 am #

      David Jeremiah is a good choice. I know that many have made the choice to worship it home. The down side is missing out on the friendship and support of other believers. One church in TItusville has a large senior’s social group that people from many churches attend.


      • Louise Gibson August 6, 2015 at 3:59 pm #

        The sad part of my story is that all the seniors left and scattered to other churches. It is an age-related problem now. I enjoy so many wonderful Christian programs on television.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Old Things R New August 6, 2015 at 7:12 pm #

        That is indeed sad. I’m glad you have found programs you enjoy.


Thank you for stopping by and reading our posts. Your comments are welcomed.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: